Mining data on mutilations, beatings,
murders
A computer programmer digs up the truth
behind atrocities in El Salvador, Kosovo and other troubled
locales.
By Simson Garfinkel - - - - - - -
- - -
September 08,
2000 | "This would be a good time to leave."
That's what Patrick Ball heard in 1992 when he
was working for the Salvadoran Human Rights Commission. Ball, a
peace activist with expertise in data mining, had spent two years in
El Salvador building a large-scale database that tracked atrocities
and human rights violations perpetrated by both the Salvadoran
government and militias during the 1970s and 1980s. It was a digital
record of this most troubled period in that country's history.
The Human Rights Commission had actually created
two databases. The first was a detailed account of threats, thefts,
beatings, mutilations, murders and massacres. This database was
largely created from eyewitness testimony -- more than 9,000 reports
in all. The second was a database that tracked the careers of El
Salvador's police and military, built largely from official records,
newspaper accounts and some personal recollections.
"What we were doing was tracking them by job,
rank and unit from when they graduated the military academy as young
lieutenants until they retired as senior colonels or generals,"
recalls Ball. "And then we crossed these two databases, by unit and
time." The technique allowed the commission to develop "statistical
human rights profiles" of individual officers and units. It showed
how units became more violent when certain officers took control,
and cataloged the crimes that had been committed under the watch of
specific individuals. Essentially, the commission had created a
Who's Who of the nastiest criminals of the country's 20-year civil
war. "And then we published them in the newspaper!"
It was a bold move for a Yankee living so far
south of the border. But the move was calculated. El Salvador was in
the middle of a closely watched transition from military to civilian
rule. "Because it was 1992, and not 1982, they didn't blow up our
office," says Ball. Instead, the people who had been named in the
files -- most of whom by then were high-ranking officials --
attacked the commission in the courts. And as for Ball, he left the
country.
It certainly wasn't what Ball had expected when
he signed up to work as a peace activist in El Salvador after
graduating from Columbia University. His first job in Central
America was as a so-called nonviolent accompaniment. "You hang
around with people who were likely targets of political violence, on
the premise that your witness would prevent people who wanted to do
political violence from doing it," he remembers. "It's interesting
work, but it's actually boring when you do it. They go to meetings,
but you sit around out front" and talk to the secretaries.
It was these secretaries who gave Ball his first
big break. To hear him tell it, the universal experience of
secretaries in offices around the world is losing files on their
computers. "If you can do anything to recover their files you become
a computer expert."
As it turns out, Ball is a computer expert. He
paid for his undergraduate education by working part time as a
database and statistics programmer. Soon after moving to El Salvador
he took a job doing computer work for the human rights office of the
Lutheran Church. From there he moved to the Human Rights Commission,
where he designed the databases to track El Salvador's bloody
history.
Next page | Turning
war stories into hard data |